Sport Compact Car Homepage
Share This Share This Num Posts    Sort Order
In the current issue of SCC i noticed an error...  
thatguy
New User | Posts: 3 | Joined: 01/07
Posted: 01/21/07
05:01 PM

Or well really I hope that it is an error.  You list the new z33 G35 sedan as being a vq35de but list it as being front wheel drive with a longitudinal engine.  I really hope nissan isnt doing this.  I myself own an s14 and would hate to see nissan take a cool car and make it like every other import sedan on the road... tell me this is an error please.

thanks,

-brad  


 
Master_Shake029
Enthusiast | Posts: 572 | Joined: 11/06
Posted: 01/21/07
08:36 PM

Well brad the G35 is just a fancy 350Z  so, yep its an error.  


Department of Labor

 
dannyf
User | Posts: 155 | Joined: 12/06
Posted: 01/22/07
04:19 PM

The car that the G35 replaced, the G20, was a great car, even if it was front-wheel-drive. There are some great cars out there that are fwd, like the Sentra SE-R or most Hondas.  


 
thatguy
New User | Posts: 3 | Joined: 01/07
Posted: 01/22/07
04:44 PM

Yea thanks, I am very well aware they are both on the z33 chassis. duhuh. haha I was just pointing this out.  FWD sucks just accept it (kidding) but the point I make is every import sedan is front wheel drive, and the fun factor is not there like in the g35.
that is all

thanks,
-brad  


 
Art of Ruin
Enthusiast | Posts: 352 | Joined: 08/06
Posted: 01/23/07
10:56 AM

I think this problem happened earlier. A reader sent a letter to the editor (that was published in a volume of SCC) that said the stats and details listed in a review of the VW GTI Mk.V were erroneous. SCC replied by saying these small previews/reviews were written by freelancers and since SCC is currently understaffed, they couldn't review every article for mistakes in time for press.  


The forum member formerly known as GTFan018
1995 Saab 900S 2.3L (Going autocrossing August 5th!)

 
2GNTEclipse
User | Posts: 224 | Joined: 11/99
Posted: 01/27/07
09:47 AM

gtfan018:
I think this problem happened earlier. A reader sent a letter to the editor (that was published in a volume of SCC) that said the stats and details listed in a review of the VW GTI Mk.V were erroneous. SCC replied by saying these small previews/reviews were written by freelancers and since SCC is currently understaffed, they couldn't review every article for mistakes in time for press.

I'd hardly consider that an excuse. They should look at any and all info that comes in to ensure it's accurate. Not doing so makes them look foolish and lazy.  


Speed and power are a mix of mostly three factors: money, motivation, and time. How fast do you want to go and how broke do you want to be when you get there?

 
cwytt
Enthusiast | Posts: 416 | Joined: 10/06
Posted: 01/28/07
12:20 PM

well mistakes happen, and this by far was a small mistake. The clue that it was a mistake was 'longitudal front wheel drive'.
I don't know of any cars with a longitudal front wheel drive system. It would have quite a crappy weight dist.  


 
thatguy
New User | Posts: 3 | Joined: 01/07
Posted: 02/01/07
09:09 PM

i believe there was an acura legend? that was longitudinal fwd no? or maybe it was something else  


 
2GNTEclipse
User | Posts: 224 | Joined: 11/99
Posted: 02/02/07
05:54 PM

Longitudially placed motors are only good for one thing: rear wheel drive. Front wheel drive cars have transversely mounted motors. They made a blatant no-no in their article, and something that blatant simply can't be written off. It's inexcusable.  


Speed and power are a mix of mostly three factors: money, motivation, and time. How fast do you want to go and how broke do you want to be when you get there?

 
Max
New User | Posts: 3 | Joined: 04/07
Posted: 04/17/07
02:11 PM

actualy, there DOES exist a longitudal FWD car... in Russia.

It's called the Moskvitch AZLK 2141. Car came with a carbed 1.7 liter, and then later, with (i think) a 2.2 liter fuel injected motor, along with cooler looking headlights, front power windows, fixed suspeansion issue, etc. (only came as manual btw)

My grandpa owned the 2141 1.7 And, while it may sound stupid, the car was actualy quite good. It pulled to about 160 kmh, in 5th. and had only about 97 whp, but it realy isn't about all that. This was the first car I worked on, helping gramps. It realy was a blast to drive, having my self proclaimed, "suicide clutch system" However, the factory that made it, went bankrupt trying to design a roadster, so parts cost soon rivaled that of an old benz. The moskvitch is one of those unique experiences that I treasure, sad to see it go.

(I moved to USA in 2000)  


 
Fish
New User | Posts: 7 | Joined: 04/07
Posted: 04/18/07
08:38 PM

Many Audi automobiles were transvers/FWD.  


 
Art of Ruin
Enthusiast | Posts: 352 | Joined: 08/06
Posted: 04/19/07
08:33 PM

Max:
actualy, there DOES exist a longitudal FWD car... in Russia.

It's called the Moskvitch AZLK 2141. Car came with a carbed 1.7 liter, and then later, with (i think) a 2.2 liter fuel injected motor, along with cooler looking headlights, front power windows, fixed suspeansion issue, etc. (only came as manual btw)

My grandpa owned the 2141 1.7 And, while it may sound stupid, the car was actualy quite good. It pulled to about 160 kmh, in 5th. and had only about 97 whp, but it realy isn't about all that. This was the first car I worked on, helping gramps. It realy was a blast to drive, having my self proclaimed, "suicide clutch system" However, the factory that made it, went bankrupt trying to design a roadster, so parts cost soon rivaled that of an old benz. The moskvitch is one of those unique experiences that I treasure, sad to see it go.

(I moved to USA in 2000)


There's another one too: 79-94 Saab 900 (aka the classic 900) was a longitudinal-engined FWD car. I don't know why Saab made them that way, but given how Saab made their cars before the GM buyout, there must be a practical reason for it (ease of maintainence is my guess).  


The forum member formerly known as GTFan018
1995 Saab 900S 2.3L (Going autocrossing August 5th!)

 
  • RSS Feed
    • Add to My Yahoo!
    • Add to Google
    • Subscribe on Bloglines
    • Subscribe on NewsGator
    • MyMSN
    • My AOL
    • Add to NetVibes
    • Add to Rojo
    • Add to NEWSBURST
    • Add to Technorati
    SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FORUMS

Car Research Guide